Melt generation during granulite-grade metamorphism is believed to be controlled by the stability temperatures of biotite, whose breakdown provides H₂O and controls fluid-absent melting in the lower crust. In a simple KMASH system, the restite minerals crystallising due to incongruent melting of phlogopite depend upon the bulk composition. In an alumina-poor and silica-rich portion of the system (Phl + Qtz), enstatite appears with the melt, while in an alumina-rich system (Phl + Sil + Qtz) cordierite appears first instead of enstatite. Since the temperature of biotite stability is believed to be strongly controlled by its F and Ti content, it will have significant effect on the fluid-absent melting reactions during granulite-grade metamorphism of mica-containing granites as well as pelitic rocks in the deeper crust.

To understand such effects in an aluminous portion of the KMASH system, experiments were performed (between 850 and 1100°C and at 7, 10 and 12 kbar) with bulk composition containing 2Phl - 6Sil - 9Qtz, where natural phlogopite with F/(F+OH) = 0.39 and Mg/(Mg+Fe) = 0.96 was used. In runs with this charge and containing 5 wt.% of excess water, cordierite appeared around 920°C at 7 kbar and 990°C at 12 kbar, and it disappeared at about 1080°C with the appearance of 221 sapphirine. In fluid-absent runs, these boundaries marginally shift to higher temperatures (30–50°C). The enstatite which was distinctly absent in H₂O-saturated runs, crystallises in the high-temperature sapphirine field with up to 12 wt.% Al₂O₃ in H₂O-undersaturated runs. The enstatite formation with cordierite is perhaps inhibited due to the Al consumption by cordierite and instability of Al-free enstatite at temperatures of cordierite stability. Re-equilibrated phlogopite persists in both the cordierite and sapphirine fields. The temperatures of the beginning of phlogopite breakdown are about 100–140°C above those reported for reaction Phl + Qtz → En + Sa + L (Vielzeuf and Clemens, 1992) with F and Ti-free phlogopite, but are ≈50–100°C lower than the temperatures reported (Tareen et al., 1995; Dooley and Patino Douce, 1996) for the same reaction containing F- and Ti- bearing phlogopite. The combined effect of the F and Ti content in phlogopite on its stability temperatures in the KMASH system has been found to be additive in relation to those containing only F or Ti. H₂O-saturated runs produced per-aluminous melts with ≈ 27 wt.% Al₂O₃ in the cordierite field and ≈23% Al₂O₃ in the sapphirine field. The H₂O-undersaturated runs produced melts rich in K₂O (≈ 10 wt.%), SiO₂ (72.5 wt.%) and relatively poor Al₂O₃ (12 wt.%).